Saturday, April 30, 2011

Supercenters and Hypermarkets (in America)

I wanted to repost this so I could re-focus on things. I reordered things, updated, added.

Since Pseudo3D's Cities and Buildings is no longer primarily about SimCity (but will still have a big focus), I wanted to show
some progress on these, plus give a bit of history. In general, hypermarkets are a type of store originated from Europe that were a high-volume combination grocery store/department store that came stateside in the late 1980s. A number of major U.S. cities got one, with Philadelphia area getting Carrefour, Houston getting Auchan, Cincinnati getting bigg's (a unique situation in that it was an entirely new chain backed by French companies), and so on. Wal-Mart, then running only discount stores, wanted in, so they partnered with Tom Thumb stores (a Dallas grocery store chain) to make Hypermart USA. Kmart partnered with Bruno's (a southern upscale-leaning grocery store chain) to make American Fare.

But when the novelty ran off, the stores became big losses, and eventually started to disappear or give way to the Superstore concept, an American-created concept where the store was downscaled from 210,000+ square feet to about 150,000 square feet, and was basically a discount store with a supermarket department.

Carrefour closed, Auchan lived, bigg's started to adapt, Wal-Mart replaced Hypermart USA with Wal-Mart Supercenter, Kmart with Super Kmart, et cetera. Today, both bigg's and Auchan are completely gone, Super Kmart is just barely hanging on, Tom Thumb and Bruno's only exist "in name only", and Wal-Mart's Supercenters have conquered America (seriously).


1. Auchan
Auchan is based after a current French hypermarket. I've talked about Auchan in great length at Two Way Roads, my now-defunct blog, so all I can say is that Auchan came stateside in 1988 to build in west Houston with big plans, but never successful enough to make a big chain. A smaller Chicago store opened in 1989 and was shuttered a few years later, and eventually, a smaller Houston store opened in 2000. Unfortunately, the combined threat of primarily H-E-B and Wal-Mart Supercenter did both in a few years later.

I put Auchan first because I was actually working on a BAT. I restarted it from what you've seen previously, which is seen below.



What went wrong? Well, there were some areas that weren't straight, plus the photo was actually not sized correctly. I rebuilt it, so that's what's here. Also, I should note, this is the second smaller location built in 2000.

See my current thread at Simtropolis.



2. bigg's
bigg's (the "b" is lowercase) opened in 1984 as America's first true "hypermarket", offering both food and general merchandise (discounting the fact that just a few states north, Meijer had been doing that for years). It was a coalition between SuperValu (owning 10%) and French companies (90%). Unfortunately, bigg's made a few mistakes in its times of operation. In 1989, a third bigg's hypermarket opened in the Denver market and the first outside of Cincinnati. The store was doomed: Wal-Mart had just set foot in the market and boasted that it was all-American unlike the partially French-owned bigg's (which WAS the truth at the time, most of Wal-Mart's products were American-made). King Soopers, owned by Kroger, ran vicious pro-union attack ads on bigg's (and Kroger was also headquartered in Cincinnati...do the math). All during that time, Hyper Shoppes insisted on building new stores not as stand-alone stores but parts of small malls that were supposed to presumably expand. The only stores that were stand-alone were just supermarkets (diluting the hypermarket brand). By the time SuperValu bought the chain in 1994, they did build stand-alone full-line stores, but scaled back square footage and never went out of the Cincinnati area. By the year 2000, bigg's was no longer building any new "hypermarket" stores and by the year 2010, SuperValu pulled the plug and sold the remnants to another grocery store.


I actually have long intended to do bigg's, but here's all I have:

It's based in Florence, Kentucky (which closed last year)










3. Super Kmart Center
I'm not sure on how to correctly say it: is it "Super Kmart" or "Super Kmart Center" or "Kmart Super Center"? Ah well. The fact is, there's about two dozen of these left, but I had fond memories of one in Waco, Texas which opened in '94 and closed in 2003. Despite the glory days of Kmart being long gone and having sunk even further than my most recent Kmart trip in '09 (in Florida), Super Ks have a lot of nostalgia value and in many ways seemed a lot better than Supercenters. The product mix was great and comparable to real supermarkets, and they had the largest food supplier at the time -Fleming- behind them. But now, with Kmart involved in probably what is the worst merger since AOL Time Warner, I don't know about them.

I snagged this store directory from Flickr, which is from 1997 (the "golden days", I think, for Super Kmart). And I've always wanted a Super Kmart for SimCity 4. Bobbo662 did create one, but no copy has yet been found. Maybe one of these I'll create one.

The above picture comes from Kmart World.


4. Walmart (Supercenter)
Wal-Mart (Supercenters) get a lot of flack for cheap products, dirty stores, and gross people that frequent it. I'm not disputing that fact, and I don't really like Walmart Supercenters that much. They profoundly cut back the SKUs (distinct products) at the local Wal-Mart when it expanded, despite it being one of the largest Wal-Marts in the country. So instead of lots of merchandise, it's short shelves, small departments, and wide aisles. The cereal aisle wasn't as good as the one in Waco that I visited before this one expanded (I had visited it after my grandfather moved to another spot in Waco shortly after the Kmart closed), it just sucked. And thanks to the pitiful selection of SKUs, we went there less often, and as a result of that, didn't really get a chance to get the Walmart rotisserie chickens, which I DID like.

More on the local Walmart here. Seems like a prime opportunity though: there's only one Wal-Mart Supercenter on the STEX, and I think I can do better. They left off the Garden Center and they say that Wal-Mart Supercenter is based in Mexico. The original creator eventually created a new Walmart based on the current model, which is far better than the old BAT. This time I can only nitpick that the "Market & Pharmacy" and "Health & Living" signs are mixed up.

There's a lot of other things I dislike about Walmart, but I won't get into them here.

5. Meijer
Meijer I HAVE been to but regrettably don't know much about. The Wikipedia article is horrifically biased (but hopefully that will clear up). The stores, sadly, are rather dated: the first one I visited was quite a let-down: low ceilings, teal, and 90s fonts. The second one was admittedly better. However, there already IS a Meijer on the SketchUp, and I'd like to one-up it by making it larger, more detailed, and et cetera. There'll even be an aluminum can deposit station (a sad reality in Michigan). However, Meijer isn't quite a hypermarket, but really isn't a supercenter either since supercenters are primarily a discount store. It's more like a supermarket with a huge general merchandise selection.

6. The Other Ones
There are plenty others not mentioned here but haven't gotten around to them. Brief blurbs about them follow.

Fred Meyer: One of the first ones to have "one-stop shopping". Unfortunately, up until the 1980s or so had separate sections that had their own checkouts and walls. No relation to Meijer.

SuperTarget: Includes a bakery and fresh produce section, but like Wal-Mart Supercenter lacks a real meat department. Kind of rare nowadays in the growing selection of "normal" food (beyond chips, candy, and soda) and the "P-Fresh" format in normal Targets.

Leedmark: A 300k square foot store in Maryland in the early 1990s. Closed, now a supermarket and a Wal-Mart Supercenter.

Hypermart USA: A short-lived experiment by Wal-Mart and had less SKUs than possibly even today's Wal-Marts (a better product mix overall, though), they were larger, featuring more food stands than the typical McDonald's or Subway found today, and so forth. From what I've read (I have no interior pics), they were more of a hybrid Sam's Club and Wal-Mart, and had extremely odd merchandising options, such as only selling white paint. By 1990, they were renaming them "Wal-Mart's Hypermart USA", and killed them a few years later.

American Fare: As mentioned above, the Super Kmart proto. However, had a different merchandise mix than Kmart, focusing on upscale clothing brands.

Carrefour: Opened a massive store in Philadelphia in the late 1980s but closed in less than a decade. Opened a second store that was also short-lived, too.

There are others I didn't mention: Fred Meyer, SuperTarget, and the obscure (and long gone) Leedmark among them. I do intend on getting to regular grocery stores and discount stores, but that's for another article.

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I would LOVE a Super Kmart for my cities. I would also love to just see a regular Kmart with the new logo. There are so many amazing varients of the regular Kmart that could be made. I really like the design of the "newer" regular Kmart stores (those built in the late 90s), but my cities would probably be incomplete without a typical 70s-style store!

    There was recently a very nice Super Target uploaded to Simtropolis.

    I wish I knew how to make these things!

    ReplyDelete